Brown does not list all presidents who were Masons. See them here on postage stamps.

5th President (1817-1825)

7th President (1829-1837)

11th President (1845-1849)

15th President (1857-1861)

17th President (1865-1869)

20th President (1881)

25th President (1897-1901)

26th President (1901-1909)

27th President (1909-1913)

29th President (1921-1923)

32nd President (1933-1945)

38th President (1974-1977)
Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and Abraham Lincoln attended Masonic gatherings and Lyndon B. Johnson initiated the process of membership but because there is not Masonic record to show the attainment of the 33rd degree they are not listed here as Masons.